{"ok":true,"version":"0.4.1","lastScored":"2026-09-28","total":30,"scoredCount":30,"policy":"Curated seed (30 sites) + open submission. Scores are deterministic: 42 checks, no LLM. Sites scoring below 50 stay listed, flagged \"needs work\". No paywall, no pay-to-remove.","sites":[{"url":"https://www.designesy.org","name":"Designesy","tier":2,"category":"Design Systems","score":93,"grade":"A","pass":39,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0,"tokens":184,"seededBecause":"Self-score: transparency earns trust. Conflict of interest: Designesy operates the scoring engine. Re-run live: /score?url=designesy.org","prevScore":93,"liveScoreUrl":"/score/report?url=designesy.org","coiDisclosure":"Self-scored by the engine operator","scoredAt":"2026-09-28","categoryScores":{"cadence":{"score":100,"weight":18,"pass":12,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"accessibility":{"score":100,"weight":15,"pass":6,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"semantic":{"score":100,"weight":12,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"motion":{"score":100,"weight":10,"pass":4,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"tokens":{"score":100,"weight":9,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"takt":{"score":100,"weight":8,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"poise":{"score":100,"weight":7,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"identity":{"score":100,"weight":6,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"interaction":{"score":100,"weight":6,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"performance":{"score":null,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"responsive":{"score":null,"weight":3,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0}},"rank":1},{"url":"https://wikipedia.org","name":"Wikipedia","tier":5,"category":"Reference","score":87.9,"grade":"B","pass":17,"fail":1,"warn":8,"skip":13,"tokens":421,"seededBecause":"High-traffic reference: minimal-design baseline","prevScore":80.7,"scoredAt":"2026-09-28","categoryScores":{"cadence":{"score":70,"weight":18,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":3,"skip":7},"accessibility":{"score":75,"weight":15,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":2,"skip":2},"semantic":{"score":100,"weight":12,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"motion":{"score":83.3,"weight":10,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":1},"tokens":{"score":100,"weight":9,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":1},"takt":{"score":75,"weight":8,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":0},"poise":{"score":100,"weight":7,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":1},"identity":{"score":100,"weight":6,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"interaction":{"score":0,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":1,"warn":0,"skip":0},"performance":{"score":null,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"responsive":{"score":null,"weight":3,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0}},"rank":2},{"url":"https://atlassian.design","name":"Atlassian Design System","tier":3,"category":"Design Systems","score":86.1,"grade":"B","pass":17,"fail":2,"warn":9,"skip":11,"tokens":28,"seededBecause":"Motion + tokens exemplar","prevScore":86.1,"scoredAt":"2026-09-28","categoryScores":{"cadence":{"score":75,"weight":18,"pass":3,"fail":0,"warn":3,"skip":6},"accessibility":{"score":62.5,"weight":15,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":3,"skip":2},"semantic":{"score":75,"weight":12,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":0},"motion":{"score":50,"weight":10,"pass":1,"fail":1,"warn":1,"skip":1},"tokens":{"score":100,"weight":9,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":1},"takt":{"score":100,"weight":8,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"poise":{"score":100,"weight":7,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":1},"identity":{"score":75,"weight":6,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":0},"interaction":{"score":100,"weight":6,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"performance":{"score":null,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"responsive":{"score":null,"weight":3,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0}},"rank":3},{"url":"https://primer.style","name":"GitHub Primer","tier":3,"category":"Design Systems","score":82.4,"grade":"B","pass":25,"fail":2,"warn":5,"skip":7,"tokens":522,"seededBecause":"Contract-adjacent","prevScore":82.4,"scoredAt":"2026-09-28","categoryScores":{"cadence":{"score":90,"weight":18,"pass":8,"fail":0,"warn":2,"skip":2},"accessibility":{"score":87.5,"weight":15,"pass":3,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":2},"semantic":{"score":50,"weight":12,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":1},"motion":{"score":66.7,"weight":10,"pass":2,"fail":1,"warn":0,"skip":1},"tokens":{"score":100,"weight":9,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":1},"takt":{"score":50,"weight":8,"pass":1,"fail":1,"warn":0,"skip":0},"poise":{"score":100,"weight":7,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"identity":{"score":100,"weight":6,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"interaction":{"score":100,"weight":6,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"performance":{"score":null,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"responsive":{"score":null,"weight":3,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0}},"rank":4},{"url":"https://apple.com","name":"Apple","tier":1,"category":"Hardware","score":82.1,"grade":"B","pass":15,"fail":2,"warn":12,"skip":10,"tokens":90,"seededBecause":"Apple HIG: tiered reduced-motion reference","prevScore":82.1,"scoredAt":"2026-09-28","categoryScores":{"cadence":{"score":64.3,"weight":18,"pass":3,"fail":1,"warn":3,"skip":5},"accessibility":{"score":75,"weight":15,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":2,"skip":2},"semantic":{"score":50,"weight":12,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":2,"skip":0},"motion":{"score":33.3,"weight":10,"pass":0,"fail":1,"warn":2,"skip":1},"tokens":{"score":100,"weight":9,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":1},"takt":{"score":100,"weight":8,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"poise":{"score":100,"weight":7,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"identity":{"score":100,"weight":6,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"interaction":{"score":100,"weight":6,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"performance":{"score":null,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"responsive":{"score":null,"weight":3,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0}},"rank":5},{"url":"https://vercel.com","name":"Vercel","tier":1,"category":"SaaS","score":81.7,"grade":"B","pass":22,"fail":2,"warn":6,"skip":9,"tokens":3,"seededBecause":"Frontier reference: Geist design system","prevScore":81.7,"scoredAt":"2026-09-28","categoryScores":{"cadence":{"score":94.4,"weight":18,"pass":8,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":3},"accessibility":{"score":62.5,"weight":15,"pass":2,"fail":1,"warn":1,"skip":2},"semantic":{"score":null,"weight":12,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"motion":{"score":50,"weight":10,"pass":1,"fail":1,"warn":1,"skip":1},"tokens":{"score":100,"weight":9,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":1},"takt":{"score":100,"weight":8,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"poise":{"score":100,"weight":7,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"identity":{"score":100,"weight":6,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"interaction":{"score":100,"weight":6,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"performance":{"score":null,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"responsive":{"score":null,"weight":3,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0}},"rank":6},{"url":"https://x.com","name":"X","tier":5,"category":"Consumer","score":81.5,"grade":"B","pass":17,"fail":0,"warn":10,"skip":12,"tokens":166,"seededBecause":"High-traffic consumer surface: a11y calibration","prevScore":82.8,"scoredAt":"2026-09-28","categoryScores":{"cadence":{"score":71.4,"weight":18,"pass":3,"fail":0,"warn":4,"skip":5},"accessibility":{"score":75,"weight":15,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":2,"skip":2},"semantic":{"score":50,"weight":12,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":2,"skip":0},"motion":{"score":100,"weight":10,"pass":3,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":1},"tokens":{"score":null,"weight":9,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"takt":{"score":50,"weight":8,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":1},"poise":{"score":100,"weight":7,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"identity":{"score":75,"weight":6,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":0},"interaction":{"score":100,"weight":6,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"performance":{"score":null,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"responsive":{"score":null,"weight":3,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0}},"rank":7},{"url":"https://figma.com","name":"Figma","tier":5,"category":"SaaS","score":76.6,"grade":"C","pass":18,"fail":1,"warn":9,"skip":11,"tokens":102,"seededBecause":"Design tool surface: token workflow origin","prevScore":76.6,"scoredAt":"2026-09-28","categoryScores":{"cadence":{"score":75,"weight":18,"pass":3,"fail":0,"warn":3,"skip":6},"accessibility":{"score":62.5,"weight":15,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":3,"skip":2},"semantic":{"score":75,"weight":12,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":0},"motion":{"score":50,"weight":10,"pass":1,"fail":1,"warn":1,"skip":1},"tokens":{"score":100,"weight":9,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":1},"takt":{"score":100,"weight":8,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"poise":{"score":100,"weight":7,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"identity":{"score":100,"weight":6,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"interaction":{"score":100,"weight":6,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"performance":{"score":null,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"responsive":{"score":null,"weight":3,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0}},"rank":8},{"url":"https://nytimes.com","name":"The New York Times","tier":1,"category":"Editorial","score":75.8,"grade":"C","pass":12,"fail":2,"warn":11,"skip":14,"tokens":85,"seededBecause":"Editorial typography: Cadence rules origin","prevScore":75.8,"scoredAt":"2026-09-22","unreachable":true,"categoryScores":{"cadence":{"score":58.3,"weight":18,"pass":3,"fail":1,"warn":8,"skip":0},"accessibility":{"score":50,"weight":15,"pass":1,"fail":1,"warn":3,"skip":1},"semantic":{"score":null,"weight":12,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"motion":{"score":50,"weight":10,"pass":2,"fail":2,"warn":0,"skip":0},"tokens":{"score":25,"weight":9,"pass":0,"fail":1,"warn":1,"skip":0},"takt":{"score":50,"weight":8,"pass":1,"fail":1,"warn":0,"skip":0},"poise":{"score":75,"weight":7,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":1},"identity":{"score":75,"weight":6,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":0},"interaction":{"score":100,"weight":6,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"performance":{"score":null,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"responsive":{"score":null,"weight":3,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0}},"rank":9},{"url":"https://designesy.ai.studio","name":"Designesy AI Studio","tier":2,"category":"Design Systems","score":74.8,"grade":"C","pass":12,"fail":1,"warn":13,"skip":13,"tokens":28,"seededBecause":"AI Studio mirror: parity relationship","prevScore":74.8,"scoredAt":"2026-09-28","categoryScores":{"cadence":{"score":66.7,"weight":18,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":4,"skip":6},"accessibility":{"score":66.7,"weight":15,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":4,"skip":0},"semantic":{"score":75,"weight":12,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":0},"motion":{"score":87.5,"weight":10,"pass":3,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":0},"tokens":{"score":100,"weight":9,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":1},"takt":{"score":null,"weight":8,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"poise":{"score":50,"weight":7,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":1},"identity":{"score":75,"weight":6,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":0},"interaction":{"score":0,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":1,"warn":0,"skip":0},"performance":{"score":null,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"responsive":{"score":null,"weight":3,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0}},"rank":10},{"url":"https://getdesy.com","name":"Desy Guard","tier":2,"category":"Design Systems","score":73.4,"grade":"C","pass":19,"fail":1,"warn":8,"skip":11,"tokens":61,"seededBecause":"AST-gate competitor","prevScore":73.4,"scoredAt":"2026-08-31","unreachable":true,"categoryScores":{"cadence":{"score":50,"weight":18,"pass":1,"fail":1,"warn":10,"skip":0},"accessibility":{"score":75,"weight":15,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":2,"skip":2},"semantic":{"score":null,"weight":12,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"motion":{"score":75,"weight":10,"pass":3,"fail":1,"warn":0,"skip":0},"tokens":{"score":100,"weight":9,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"takt":{"score":50,"weight":8,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":2,"skip":0},"poise":{"score":75,"weight":7,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":1},"identity":{"score":100,"weight":6,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"interaction":{"score":100,"weight":6,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"performance":{"score":null,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"responsive":{"score":null,"weight":3,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0}},"rank":11},{"url":"https://roastbyai.com","name":"Roast by AI","tier":2,"category":"Design Systems","score":71.2,"grade":"C","pass":18,"fail":1,"warn":8,"skip":12,"tokens":46,"seededBecause":"Roast competitor: leaderboard model reference","prevScore":71.2,"scoredAt":"2026-09-28","categoryScores":{"cadence":{"score":85.7,"weight":18,"pass":5,"fail":0,"warn":2,"skip":5},"accessibility":{"score":62.5,"weight":15,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":3,"skip":2},"semantic":{"score":75,"weight":12,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":0},"motion":{"score":66.7,"weight":10,"pass":2,"fail":1,"warn":0,"skip":1},"tokens":{"score":100,"weight":9,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":1},"takt":{"score":50,"weight":8,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":1},"poise":{"score":100,"weight":7,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":1},"identity":{"score":100,"weight":6,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"interaction":{"score":100,"weight":6,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"performance":{"score":null,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"responsive":{"score":null,"weight":3,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0}},"rank":12},{"url":"https://awwwards.com","name":"Awwwards","tier":4,"category":"Inspiration","score":70.3,"grade":"C","pass":14,"fail":3,"warn":11,"skip":11,"tokens":98,"seededBecause":"Exemplar discovery surface","prevScore":71.6,"scoredAt":"2026-09-28","categoryScores":{"cadence":{"score":75,"weight":18,"pass":3,"fail":0,"warn":3,"skip":6},"accessibility":{"score":66.7,"weight":15,"pass":3,"fail":1,"warn":2,"skip":0},"semantic":{"score":75,"weight":12,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":0},"motion":{"score":33.3,"weight":10,"pass":0,"fail":1,"warn":2,"skip":1},"tokens":{"score":100,"weight":9,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"takt":{"score":50,"weight":8,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":1},"poise":{"score":50,"weight":7,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":1},"identity":{"score":100,"weight":6,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"interaction":{"score":0,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":1,"warn":0,"skip":0},"performance":{"score":null,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"responsive":{"score":null,"weight":3,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0}},"rank":13},{"url":"https://zeroheight.com","name":"zeroheight","tier":2,"category":"Design Systems","score":70,"grade":"C","pass":19,"fail":2,"warn":8,"skip":10,"tokens":183,"seededBecause":"DTCG 2025.10 incumbent","prevScore":70,"scoredAt":"2026-09-28","categoryScores":{"cadence":{"score":77.8,"weight":18,"pass":6,"fail":1,"warn":2,"skip":3},"accessibility":{"score":50,"weight":15,"pass":1,"fail":1,"warn":2,"skip":2},"semantic":{"score":50,"weight":12,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":2,"skip":0},"motion":{"score":100,"weight":10,"pass":3,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":1},"tokens":{"score":100,"weight":9,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":1},"takt":{"score":100,"weight":8,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":1},"poise":{"score":100,"weight":7,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":1},"identity":{"score":100,"weight":6,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"interaction":{"score":100,"weight":6,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"performance":{"score":null,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"responsive":{"score":null,"weight":3,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0}},"rank":14},{"url":"https://vam.ac.uk","name":"V&A Museum","tier":4,"category":"Cultural","score":70,"grade":"C","pass":14,"fail":3,"warn":9,"skip":13,"tokens":51,"seededBecause":"Pentagram brand identity case study","prevScore":70,"scoredAt":"2026-09-28","categoryScores":{"cadence":{"score":58.3,"weight":18,"pass":2,"fail":1,"warn":3,"skip":6},"accessibility":{"score":50,"weight":15,"pass":1,"fail":1,"warn":2,"skip":2},"semantic":{"score":75,"weight":12,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":0},"motion":{"score":50,"weight":10,"pass":1,"fail":1,"warn":1,"skip":1},"tokens":{"score":null,"weight":9,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"takt":{"score":75,"weight":8,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":0},"poise":{"score":100,"weight":7,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":1},"identity":{"score":100,"weight":6,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"interaction":{"score":100,"weight":6,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"performance":{"score":null,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"responsive":{"score":null,"weight":3,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0}},"rank":15},{"url":"https://linear.app","name":"Linear","tier":1,"category":"SaaS","score":69.5,"grade":"D","pass":20,"fail":2,"warn":10,"skip":7,"tokens":191,"seededBecause":"Frontier reference: invariant-craft tier","prevScore":69.5,"scoredAt":"2026-09-28","categoryScores":{"cadence":{"score":88.9,"weight":18,"pass":7,"fail":0,"warn":2,"skip":3},"accessibility":{"score":37.5,"weight":15,"pass":0,"fail":1,"warn":3,"skip":2},"semantic":{"score":50,"weight":12,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":2,"skip":0},"motion":{"score":50,"weight":10,"pass":1,"fail":1,"warn":1,"skip":1},"tokens":{"score":100,"weight":9,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":1},"takt":{"score":100,"weight":8,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"poise":{"score":100,"weight":7,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"identity":{"score":100,"weight":6,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"interaction":{"score":100,"weight":6,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"performance":{"score":null,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"responsive":{"score":null,"weight":3,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0}},"rank":16},{"url":"https://github.com","name":"GitHub","tier":5,"category":"SaaS","score":68.5,"grade":"D","pass":23,"fail":3,"warn":6,"skip":7,"tokens":576,"seededBecause":"High-traffic dev surface: Primer in production","prevScore":68.5,"scoredAt":"2026-09-28","categoryScores":{"cadence":{"score":81.8,"weight":18,"pass":8,"fail":1,"warn":2,"skip":1},"accessibility":{"score":62.5,"weight":15,"pass":2,"fail":1,"warn":1,"skip":2},"semantic":{"score":50,"weight":12,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":1},"motion":{"score":66.7,"weight":10,"pass":2,"fail":1,"warn":0,"skip":1},"tokens":{"score":100,"weight":9,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":1},"takt":{"score":100,"weight":8,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"poise":{"score":100,"weight":7,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"identity":{"score":100,"weight":6,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"interaction":{"score":100,"weight":6,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"performance":{"score":null,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"responsive":{"score":null,"weight":3,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0}},"rank":17},{"url":"https://m3.material.io","name":"Material 3","tier":3,"category":"Design Systems","score":67.6,"grade":"D","pass":7,"fail":2,"warn":12,"skip":18,"tokens":158,"seededBecause":"MotionScheme + Sound: closest to designesy combo","prevScore":67.6,"scoredAt":"2026-09-28","categoryScores":{"cadence":{"score":40,"weight":18,"pass":0,"fail":1,"warn":4,"skip":7},"accessibility":{"score":50,"weight":15,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":4,"skip":2},"semantic":{"score":75,"weight":12,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":0},"motion":{"score":83.3,"weight":10,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":1},"tokens":{"score":100,"weight":9,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":1},"takt":{"score":null,"weight":8,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"poise":{"score":50,"weight":7,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":1},"identity":{"score":75,"weight":6,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":0},"interaction":{"score":0,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":1,"warn":0,"skip":0},"performance":{"score":null,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"responsive":{"score":null,"weight":3,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0}},"rank":18},{"url":"https://stripe.com","name":"Stripe","tier":1,"category":"SaaS","score":66.9,"grade":"D","pass":18,"fail":1,"warn":11,"skip":9,"tokens":714,"seededBecause":"Frontier reference: mature design system","prevScore":66.9,"scoredAt":"2026-09-28","categoryScores":{"cadence":{"score":87.5,"weight":18,"pass":6,"fail":0,"warn":2,"skip":4},"accessibility":{"score":50,"weight":15,"pass":1,"fail":1,"warn":2,"skip":2},"semantic":{"score":50,"weight":12,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":2,"skip":0},"motion":{"score":83.3,"weight":10,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":1},"tokens":{"score":100,"weight":9,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":1},"takt":{"score":100,"weight":8,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"poise":{"score":100,"weight":7,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"identity":{"score":75,"weight":6,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":0},"interaction":{"score":100,"weight":6,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"performance":{"score":null,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"responsive":{"score":null,"weight":3,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0}},"rank":19},{"url":"https://notion.so","name":"Notion","tier":5,"category":"SaaS","score":65,"grade":"D","pass":16,"fail":4,"warn":9,"skip":10,"tokens":544,"seededBecause":"Product surface: Linear/Stripe competitor","prevScore":65,"scoredAt":"2026-09-28","categoryScores":{"cadence":{"score":68.8,"weight":18,"pass":4,"fail":1,"warn":3,"skip":4},"accessibility":{"score":50,"weight":15,"pass":1,"fail":1,"warn":2,"skip":2},"semantic":{"score":50,"weight":12,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":2,"skip":0},"motion":{"score":50,"weight":10,"pass":1,"fail":1,"warn":1,"skip":1},"tokens":{"score":100,"weight":9,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":1},"takt":{"score":50,"weight":8,"pass":1,"fail":1,"warn":0,"skip":0},"poise":{"score":100,"weight":7,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":1},"identity":{"score":100,"weight":6,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"interaction":{"score":100,"weight":6,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"performance":{"score":null,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"responsive":{"score":null,"weight":3,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0}},"rank":20},{"url":"https://radix-ui.com","name":"Radix Colors","tier":3,"category":"Design Systems","score":63.2,"grade":"D","pass":14,"fail":3,"warn":12,"skip":10,"tokens":59,"seededBecause":"12-step semantic color","prevScore":63.2,"scoredAt":"2026-09-28","categoryScores":{"cadence":{"score":64.3,"weight":18,"pass":3,"fail":1,"warn":3,"skip":5},"accessibility":{"score":37.5,"weight":15,"pass":0,"fail":1,"warn":3,"skip":2},"semantic":{"score":50,"weight":12,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":2,"skip":0},"motion":{"score":33.3,"weight":10,"pass":0,"fail":1,"warn":2,"skip":1},"tokens":{"score":100,"weight":9,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":1},"takt":{"score":100,"weight":8,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"poise":{"score":100,"weight":7,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"identity":{"score":75,"weight":6,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":0},"interaction":{"score":100,"weight":6,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"performance":{"score":null,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"responsive":{"score":null,"weight":3,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0}},"rank":21},{"url":"https://mozaika.design","name":"Mozaika","tier":2,"category":"Design Systems","score":62.8,"grade":"D","pass":6,"fail":1,"warn":12,"skip":20,"tokens":0,"seededBecause":"Closest competitor: 0-100 score comparison","prevScore":62.8,"scoredAt":"2026-09-28","categoryScores":{"cadence":{"score":60,"weight":18,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":4,"skip":7},"accessibility":{"score":50,"weight":15,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":4,"skip":2},"semantic":{"score":null,"weight":12,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"motion":{"score":83.3,"weight":10,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":1},"tokens":{"score":null,"weight":9,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"takt":{"score":null,"weight":8,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"poise":{"score":50,"weight":7,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":1},"identity":{"score":75,"weight":6,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":0},"interaction":{"score":0,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":1,"warn":0,"skip":0},"performance":{"score":null,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"responsive":{"score":null,"weight":3,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0}},"rank":22},{"url":"https://geist.dev","name":"Vercel Geist","tier":3,"category":"Design Systems","score":62,"grade":"D","pass":7,"fail":1,"warn":10,"skip":21,"tokens":0,"seededBecause":".md-for-agents pattern (replaced dead geist-ui.com)","prevScore":62,"scoredAt":"2026-09-28","categoryScores":{"cadence":{"score":60,"weight":18,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":4,"skip":7},"accessibility":{"score":62.5,"weight":15,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":3,"skip":2},"semantic":{"score":null,"weight":12,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"motion":{"score":83.3,"weight":10,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":1},"tokens":{"score":null,"weight":9,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"takt":{"score":null,"weight":8,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"poise":{"score":50,"weight":7,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":1},"identity":{"score":75,"weight":6,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":0},"interaction":{"score":0,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":1,"warn":0,"skip":0},"performance":{"score":null,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"responsive":{"score":null,"weight":3,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0}},"rank":23},{"url":"https://stitch.withgoogle.com","name":"Google Stitch","tier":2,"category":"Design Systems","score":61.2,"grade":"D","pass":7,"fail":1,"warn":11,"skip":20,"tokens":2,"seededBecause":"DESIGN.md ecosystem","prevScore":61.2,"scoredAt":"2026-09-28","categoryScores":{"cadence":{"score":60,"weight":18,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":4,"skip":7},"accessibility":{"score":62.5,"weight":15,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":3,"skip":2},"semantic":{"score":null,"weight":12,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"motion":{"score":83.3,"weight":10,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":1},"tokens":{"score":null,"weight":9,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"takt":{"score":null,"weight":8,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"poise":{"score":50,"weight":7,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":1},"identity":{"score":75,"weight":6,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":0},"interaction":{"score":0,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":1,"warn":0,"skip":0},"performance":{"score":null,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"responsive":{"score":null,"weight":3,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0}},"rank":24},{"url":"https://carbondesignsystem.com","name":"IBM Carbon","tier":3,"category":"Design Systems","score":60.7,"grade":"D","pass":14,"fail":4,"warn":6,"skip":15,"tokens":15,"seededBecause":"Mature token system","prevScore":60.7,"scoredAt":"2026-09-28","categoryScores":{"cadence":{"score":66.7,"weight":18,"pass":3,"fail":1,"warn":2,"skip":6},"accessibility":{"score":62.5,"weight":15,"pass":2,"fail":1,"warn":1,"skip":2},"semantic":{"score":null,"weight":12,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"motion":{"score":50,"weight":10,"pass":1,"fail":1,"warn":1,"skip":1},"tokens":{"score":null,"weight":9,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"takt":{"score":75,"weight":8,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":0},"poise":{"score":100,"weight":7,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":1},"identity":{"score":50,"weight":6,"pass":1,"fail":1,"warn":0,"skip":0},"interaction":{"score":100,"weight":6,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"performance":{"score":null,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"responsive":{"score":null,"weight":3,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0}},"rank":25},{"url":"https://spectrum.adobe.com","name":"Adobe Spectrum","tier":3,"category":"Design Systems","score":58.9,"grade":"F","pass":7,"fail":2,"warn":12,"skip":18,"tokens":0,"seededBecause":"Motion $type reference","prevScore":58.9,"scoredAt":"2026-09-28","categoryScores":{"cadence":{"score":50,"weight":18,"pass":1,"fail":1,"warn":5,"skip":5},"accessibility":{"score":62.5,"weight":15,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":3,"skip":2},"semantic":{"score":null,"weight":12,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"motion":{"score":83.3,"weight":10,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":1},"tokens":{"score":null,"weight":9,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"takt":{"score":null,"weight":8,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"poise":{"score":50,"weight":7,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":1},"identity":{"score":75,"weight":6,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":0},"interaction":{"score":0,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":1,"warn":0,"skip":0},"performance":{"score":null,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"responsive":{"score":null,"weight":3,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0}},"rank":26},{"url":"https://plex.ibm.com","name":"IBM Plex","tier":3,"category":"Typography","score":58.3,"grade":"F","pass":7,"fail":2,"warn":12,"skip":18,"tokens":0,"seededBecause":"Org-first type system","prevScore":58.3,"scoredAt":"2026-09-28","categoryScores":{"cadence":{"score":40,"weight":18,"pass":0,"fail":1,"warn":4,"skip":7},"accessibility":{"score":50,"weight":15,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":4,"skip":2},"semantic":{"score":null,"weight":12,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"motion":{"score":83.3,"weight":10,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":1},"tokens":{"score":null,"weight":9,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"takt":{"score":null,"weight":8,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"poise":{"score":50,"weight":7,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":1},"identity":{"score":75,"weight":6,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":0},"interaction":{"score":0,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":1,"warn":0,"skip":0},"performance":{"score":null,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"responsive":{"score":null,"weight":3,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0}},"rank":27},{"url":"https://pentagram.com","name":"Pentagram","tier":4,"category":"Agency","score":55.2,"grade":"F","pass":11,"fail":2,"warn":12,"skip":14,"tokens":181,"seededBecause":"Parent-system posture analog","prevScore":48.3,"scoredAt":"2026-09-28","categoryScores":{"cadence":{"score":58.3,"weight":18,"pass":2,"fail":1,"warn":3,"skip":6},"accessibility":{"score":62.5,"weight":15,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":3,"skip":2},"semantic":{"score":50,"weight":12,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":2,"skip":0},"motion":{"score":50,"weight":10,"pass":1,"fail":1,"warn":1,"skip":1},"tokens":{"score":100,"weight":9,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":1},"takt":{"score":null,"weight":8,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"poise":{"score":100,"weight":7,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":1},"identity":{"score":75,"weight":6,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":0},"interaction":{"score":100,"weight":6,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"performance":{"score":null,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"responsive":{"score":null,"weight":3,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0}},"rank":28},{"url":"https://fwa.org","name":"FWA","tier":4,"category":"Inspiration","score":48,"grade":"F","pass":8,"fail":3,"warn":13,"skip":15,"tokens":44,"seededBecause":"Creative exemplars","prevScore":48,"scoredAt":"2026-09-28","categoryScores":{"cadence":{"score":57.1,"weight":18,"pass":2,"fail":1,"warn":4,"skip":5},"accessibility":{"score":37.5,"weight":15,"pass":0,"fail":1,"warn":3,"skip":2},"semantic":{"score":50,"weight":12,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":1},"motion":{"score":83.3,"weight":10,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":1},"tokens":{"score":100,"weight":9,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":1},"takt":{"score":null,"weight":8,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"poise":{"score":50,"weight":7,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":1},"identity":{"score":75,"weight":6,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":1,"skip":0},"interaction":{"score":0,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":1,"warn":0,"skip":0},"performance":{"score":null,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"responsive":{"score":null,"weight":3,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0}},"rank":29},{"url":"https://cssdesignawards.com","name":"CSS Design Awards","tier":4,"category":"Inspiration","score":44.9,"grade":"F","pass":6,"fail":3,"warn":14,"skip":16,"tokens":0,"seededBecause":"Design awards","prevScore":44.9,"scoredAt":"2026-08-31","unreachable":true,"categoryScores":{"cadence":{"score":54.2,"weight":18,"pass":1,"fail":0,"warn":11,"skip":0},"accessibility":{"score":40,"weight":15,"pass":0,"fail":1,"warn":4,"skip":1},"semantic":{"score":null,"weight":12,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"motion":{"score":37.5,"weight":10,"pass":1,"fail":2,"warn":1,"skip":0},"tokens":{"score":0,"weight":9,"pass":0,"fail":1,"warn":0,"skip":1},"takt":{"score":25,"weight":8,"pass":0,"fail":1,"warn":1,"skip":0},"poise":{"score":50,"weight":7,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":2,"skip":1},"identity":{"score":100,"weight":6,"pass":2,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"interaction":{"score":0,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":1,"warn":0,"skip":0},"performance":{"score":null,"weight":6,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0},"responsive":{"score":null,"weight":3,"pass":0,"fail":0,"warn":0,"skip":0}},"rank":30}]}